Three Crucial SCOTUS Cases Could Restore the Founders’ Vision for Religious Liberty
Three pivotal religious liberty cases before the Supreme Court this month could redefine how faith-based rights are protected across education, charity, and parental authority in America.
Case 1 – Catholic Charity in Wisconsin: The first case addresses whether a Catholic social service organization in Wisconsin qualifies for a tax exemption under state law. The Wisconsin Supreme Court denied the exemption, claiming the charity’s services (though faith-motivated) were too secular to merit religious tax status. The Supreme Court's decision could significantly impact the ability of faith-based charities nationwide to operate without undue financial burdens.
Case 2 – Catholic Charter School in Oklahoma: The second case involves the constitutionality of a proposed Catholic charter school in Oklahoma. The state’s Supreme Court struck down the approval of the school, arguing that charter schools must remain secular as public institutions. This case challenges whether religious organizations can participate in state charter programs without violating the Establishment Clause.
Case 3 – Parental Rights in Maryland: The third case considers whether parents in Maryland can opt their children out of school lessons that include sexual content and LGBT themes, which the parents argue conflicts with their religious beliefs. The school district removed opt-out provisions and stopped notifying parents of such content, prompting a lawsuit claiming violations of religious freedom and parental rights under the First Amendment and due process protections.
The Court is expected to rule by June 2025. A strong affirmation of religious liberty could mark a vital course correction, restoring First Amendment protections and re-aligning America with its founding vision of faith, conscience, and limited government rooted in moral order.